News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Pokies pain: clubs predict job losses after gambling reform 

Pokies pain: clubs predict job losses after gambling reform

15 Jun, 2011 04:59 AM
THE Telegraph Hotel could close and at least 20 jobs will be lost in Tenterfield if local pubs and clubs are forced to put in place a new pre-commitment scheme on poker machines.

At a meeting last Wednesday, the managers of some of the pubs and clubs around town presented the figures, which they say will cripple their businesses and destroy the town’s social life and community spirit.

The Federal Government introduced the pre-commitment scheme last year in return for the support of Tasmanian Independent, Andrew Wilkie, who wants to curb problem gambling across the country.

Under the proposed policy, people would be forced to register for a licence before playing the pokies. Limits would also be placed on the amount of money people can put in.

The reforms could be introduced by 2014, with pubs and clubs with under 15 machines given a reprieve until 2018.

Manager at the Telegraph Hotel, Scott Shearer, said the reforms would send him broke and force him to close down.

He said he would have to outlay at least $175,000 to buy the new machines and would not be able to recoup the costs in others areas.

“We’re barely surviving as it is,” Mr Shearer said. “You don’t make all your money from pokies but they do contribute to the running of things.

“There is no way I can put up my prices, my customers wouldn’t be able to pay them.”

Tenterfield Bowling Club general manager Michael Jones said it would cost him at least $105,000 to install the new technology in 21 of the 33 poker machines at the club.

He said under the proposed scheme, the club was set to lose up to 40 per cent of its annual profit, leading to a loss of $24,000 dollars a month or $288,000 a year.

For Tenterfield Golf Club manager Mitchell Clark, the loss could be anywhere above $100,000.

“These new poker machine reforms are going to have a very massive, very negative impact on the community, there will be job losses and less community involvement at the clubs,” he said

Scott Shearer said if the Telegraph went under, the 18 staff he employed would be out of a job. The bowling club currently employs about 12-15 people and Mr Jones said it was likely three to four jobs would have to be cut if the club was to survive.

Royal Hotel Motel manager Kevin Graham said the impacts would be felt throughout the community.

“It isn’t just the people in pubs and clubs that are going to be affected by these changes,” he said.

“It will be like dominoes, once one goes, everything will follow.”

Tenterfield Bowling Club president Dick Peters said the bowling club provided about $18,000 a year in sponsorship to many local sporting groups and community organisations

“Every month we get letters asking us for support and contributions and these will have to stop, at the very least the fees for bowlers will have to increase,” he said.

Mr Peters said for many of the town’s older population, going to the local pub or club for an afternoon was an important social outing that would no doubt be reduced if they could no longer afford the fees.

Mr Shearer said the social life of Tenterfield’s young people would also be reduced.

“The town will be dead. There will be no live music in any of the pubs and not much other entertainment around the place,” he said.

Mr Clark said if pubs and clubs had any hope of surviving the changes, they would need to diversify the kind of services they offered to their customers.

“It is the duty of our business to not rely so heavily on the revenue provided by the pokies and instead look at other services - for us it will be about promoting the game of golf,” he said.

But Mr Jones said many clubs would not be able to cover costs elsewhere.

“Keno and TAB barely generate enough to cover their running costs, especially with the rising cost of electricity,” Mr Jones said.

“People will just look to other things, like online games if they want to gamble,” Mr Graham said.

“The government hasn’t thought through this policy at all.

“They are putting restrictions on everybody, when the gamblers make-up less than one per cent of the Australian population.”

Minister for Families and Community Services Jenny Macklin has said one in six people who play the pokies regularly has a serious addiction.

She said the federal government understands the challenges small venues face in rural communities

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This report contains inaccuracies. It is poor journalism that this reporter did not question the basis of these claims.

The truth is that 'nearly there' systems that have been working for years require no capital cost and only a small daily charge of $1.50 per day per pokie.

Furthermore, there is no basis for the estimates of revenue loss. They are speculative.

The modest consumer protection measures were not Mr Wilkie's concept. They were the considered recommendations of the Productivity Commission reached after 11 years of study and full consultation with the pokie industry.

Posted by Paul Bendat, 15/06/2011 5:41:30 AM, on Tenterfield Star
Research from Nova Scotia (where players of gaming machines voluntarily set their own limit) shows that the introduction of a mandatory sign up/voluntary precommitment limit setting system proposed by Wilkie, is a profit reduction in the order of 10% - not 40%.

For Tenterfield Golf Club, that will mean profits will drop by $6,000 per month, not $24,000 per month. The club will still get $54,000 clear profit each month from customers living in the Tenterfield community AND the $6000 profit the club won't make will be spent in other businesses making them more able to employ more staff.


Posted by Sue Pinkerton, 15/06/2011 10:48:12 AM, on Tenterfield Star
Mr. Jones, I'm just considering the arguments from your esteemed peak body Clubs Australia. This of course depends on which argument you decide to run with but maybe some problem gamblers will shift over to Keno/Tab therefore boosting that revenue. After all according to the learned wisdom of CA gambling addicts aren't fussy. I hear you say they will go online Mr. Graham but they can do that now so perhaps many of them will still prefer the camaraderie etc of being at the club and this includes recreational gamblers despite the non event of having to sign up for a card if necessary.
Posted by Ellie, 15/06/2011 5:10:35 PM, on Tenterfield Star
bottom line is that any business that relies upon money from pokie addicts should be shut down. Pubs existed for hundreds of years before pokies were invented, why not now when gamblers are able to set their own limits on how much they want to spend?
Posted by Peter B, 15/06/2011 9:52:54 PM, on Tenterfield Star
Those who currently profit from gambling will exaggerate their posible losses. However, that does not mean the community should believe them.

It makes sense (@Sue, 15 06 is right) - money will be spent more appropriately, and the fear of job losses is just spin.

Posted by Alec Hones, 16/06/2011 8:23:53 AM, on Tenterfield Star
If poker machines are a source of problem gambling what about the myriad of other avenues for gambling? Has no one lost all their money at the races? Seems everyone buys Lotto tickets. Perhaps playing real poker with cards should be banned. Ban this. Ban that. Why not ban alcohol which destroys even more lives? Oh, that's right...it was tried in USA and it failed except for Al Capone and others. What people do with their own money is their business and no one else's.
Posted by horses, 22/06/2011 12:52:03 PM, on Tenterfield Star
Peter B has hit the nail on the head - well said. The outcry from these businesses goes to show how much they rely on people LOSING!!! their hard earned money to which they can now keep to pay for the increase in living expences like electricity and food.
Posted by robert m, 23/06/2011 8:39:40 PM, on Tenterfield Star
As Chair of the NSW Responsible Gambling Fund I continue to be disappointed with the response of the gambling industry to the proposed reforms. Any business which bases its profits on exploiting vulnerable people has a problem that must be ultimately addressed. Gambling operators should be welcoming these harm minimisation measures to protect their clients and help make gambling a clean and safe industry.
Posted by Rev. Harry Herbert, 24/06/2011 3:26:04 PM, on Tenterfield Star

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Fears for the future: Telegraph Hotel Scott Shearer says poker machine reforms could close the hotel.
Fears for the future: Telegraph Hotel Scott Shearer says poker machine reforms could close the hotel.

Most popular articles




Tenterfield Star







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...